23XI Insider Slams NASCAR's Pit-Stop Qualifying Plan as a 'Gimmick'
Essentially Sports · November 10, 2026
Key takeaways
- NASCAR is considering adding pit stops to qualifying at select tracks starting in 2027, per President of Event Management John Probst.
- A 23XI Racing spotter publicly called the idea a 'gimmick' that belongs in the All-Star Race, not point races with championship implications.
- Not all insiders agree — veteran crew chief Tommy Baldwin Jr. says he's involved in discussions and supports making qualifying more of a team effort.
NASCAR can't stop tinkering with its format, and the latest idea has already sparked backlash from inside the garage.
What NASCAR Is Proposing John Probst, NASCAR's President of Event Management, confirmed the sanctioning body is exploring an All-Star-style qualifying format for select tracks starting in 2027. The twist? Teams would complete an actual pit stop during their timed qualifying attempt, turning a solo speed test into a group effort that includes the pit crew's performance.
This isn't happening in a vacuum. NASCAR has already announced the Chase format's return for 2026 and tweaked its rainout lineup procedures, signaling a broader appetite for format experimentation heading into the next few seasons.
The Pushback From the Garage Not everyone is on board. On the Door Bumper Clear podcast, a 23XI Racing spotter didn't hold back, calling the pit-stop qualifying concept exactly what it sounds like: a gimmick. His argument is straightforward — stunts like this have a place in exhibition events like the All-Star Race, where nothing but prize money and bragging rights are on the line. Point races are different. When championship implications and playoff seeding are in the mix, he argues, the sport should stick to a clean, straightforward test of speed rather than introducing more variables that could be influenced by pit crew execution rather than raw lap times.
Interestingly, not everyone in the conversation agreed. Tommy Baldwin Jr., a veteran crew chief and former team owner, revealed he'd been part of some of the internal discussions around the idea and said he was genuinely excited about making qualifying more of a team-wide exercise rather than just a driver-and-car showcase.
Why the Disagreement Matters This split captures a real tension in modern NASCAR: how much should the sport evolve its traditional formats to boost entertainment value, versus preserving the integrity of competition for events that count toward a driver's championship run. Qualifying has historically been one of the purest tests in racing — one car, one driver, one clock. Adding a pit stop element introduces human error, strategy, and team performance into what's supposed to be an individual measurement of speed.
What Happens Next NASCAR hasn't finalized which tracks, if any, would adopt this format in 2027, and Probst's comments suggest this is still in the discussion phase rather than a locked-in rule change. Expect more pushback from drivers, crew chiefs, and spotters as the idea gains traction, especially if NASCAR tries to roll it out at tracks that matter for playoff positioning. For now, it's a proposal — but one that's already proven divisive before a single pit stop has happened during a qualifying session.
Why it matters
If NASCAR implements pit-stop qualifying at point races, it could change how teams prepare for and execute race weekends, adding pit crew performance to what's historically been a pure speed contest. For fans and bettors alike, this debate shapes how seriously NASCAR is willing to mess with traditional formats in the name of entertainment.
Want deals on what you love?
Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.
Meet Val