ValyouNewsExploreMeet Val
Sports

John Harbaugh Called Titans Owner Directly in Failed Jeffery Simmons Trade Push

Essentially Sports · October 31, 2026

Key takeaways

The Move That Broke NFL Protocol

Trade talks between front offices usually stay between GMs. John Harbaugh decided that wasn't fast enough. With the Giants hunting for help on the defensive line ahead of the November 10 trade deadline, Harbaugh reportedly went around Titans GM Mike Borgonzi and called team owner Amy Adams Strunk directly to push for a deal involving All-Pro defensive tackle Jeffery Simmons.

That's not how this is supposed to work. Coaches don't typically cold-call rival owners mid-negotiation — GMs handle trade logistics, and head coaches weigh in internally. But Harbaugh isn't operating under typical structure in New York.

Why Harbaugh Had the Juice to Try It

When the Giants hired Harbaugh, the arrangement came with an unusual wrinkle: he reports directly to ownership, not to GM Joe Schoen. That setup gives Harbaugh real pull over football decisions, and it explains why he felt comfortable making a call most coaches wouldn't dream of.

Schoen had already tried the normal route, reaching out to Borgonzi about Simmons. Borgonzi said no — the Titans weren't moving him, full stop, and he told other interested teams the same thing. Harbaugh, apparently unconvinced that Borgonzi's answer was final, decided to take his case straight to the top.

Strunk Shut It Down

It didn't work. Amy Adams Strunk made clear to Harbaugh that she'd handed football decisions to Borgonzi and had zero interest in overruling her GM, even for a direct ask from an opposing head coach. Harbaugh got the same no he'd already heard — just from a different person.

The Titans ultimately moved on without a Giants deal, sending Simmons to the Chicago Bears instead.

Why This Story Has Legs

Beyond the Simmons trade itself, this is a glimpse into how unusual the Giants' power structure really is. A head coach with enough standing to bypass his own team's GM-to-GM backchannel and dial up an opposing owner is rare in the modern NFL, where front offices are typically walled off from coaching staffs. It also says something about Harbaugh's urgency: the Giants are sitting atop the NFC East heading into Week 9, and he clearly believes this roster is good enough right now to go all-in on upgrades.

For Giants fans, the takeaway isn't really about missing out on Simmons — it's about what Harbaugh's willingness to break norms says about how aggressive this front office (and coaching staff) plans to be before the deadline closes.

Why it matters

This shows just how much power John Harbaugh holds within the Giants organization — enough to skip normal front-office channels entirely. For fans tracking New York's deadline moves, it's a signal the team is pushing hard to upgrade a roster currently leading the NFC East.

#NFL#New York Giants#John Harbaugh#Jeffery Simmons#Tennessee Titans

Source: Essentially Sports

Want deals on what you love?

Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.

Meet Val