Midseason All-NFC East Team: Best Players in the NFL's Most Cursed Division
Fansided · November 7, 2026
Key takeaways
- J.J. McCarthy has emerged as the surprising top quarterback performer in the NFC East despite limited playing time with the Giants.
- Saquon Barkley remains the standout running back in a division lacking star power at most other positions.
- The NFC East appears headed toward another low-win division title, continuing a pattern since the 2011 Giants' Super Bowl run.
The NFC East has a curse problem. Ever since the 2011 Giants won the division with a mediocre 9-7 record and then somehow rode that momentum to a Super Bowl title, the football gods have apparently decided this division deserves periodic chaos. Three times since then, a team has claimed the NFC East crown with single-digit wins — and this season looks like it's shaping up to be number four.
But even in a division where nobody looks complete, somebody has to be the best of the bunch. So let's build out a midseason All-NFC East roster using the one rule that actually matters: who's playing well *right now*, not who's done it before or who might do it later.
The Quarterback Surprise
Here's the twist nobody saw coming — the best quarterback play in the division right now belongs to J.J. McCarthy of the Giants. He's logged all of 97 snaps and started a single game. That's it. That's the bar right now in the NFC East.
What makes McCarthy's case legitimate instead of a fluke is where the good tape came from. His strong showings happened against teams *outside* the division, while other NFC East quarterbacks have only flashed well in divisional matchups — games that tend to be sloppy and low-stakes in terms of real evaluation. When your best quarterback performances come against non-rivals, that actually means something.
Running Back Still Has Star Power
If there's one position where the division isn't scraping the bottom of the barrel, it's running back. Saquon Barkley continues to anchor the Eagles' offense, proving that even on a team searching for consistency, elite backfield talent still shows up on tape. There's a case to be made for Javonte Williams putting together his own quietly strong season, but Barkley's overall body of work keeps him in the driver's seat for this spot.
Why This Roster Matters
This isn't about ranking the best players in football. It's about recognizing bright spots in a division that, frankly, nobody expects much from this year. The NFC East has become the league's reliable source of weirdness — a place where one hot stretch from a backup quarterback can genuinely be the best thing happening at the position.
What to Watch Going Forward
Keep an eye on whether McCarthy gets more run as the Giants sort out their quarterback situation, and watch if Barkley can keep carrying Philadelphia's offense through a season that's been far from smooth. With a division this unpredictable, the storylines are going to keep shifting fast — and that's exactly what makes the NFC East worth watching, cursed or not.
Why it matters
NFC East fans know this division rarely makes sense, and tracking who's actually performing well midseason helps separate real breakout stories from preseason hype. For fantasy football managers and bettors alike, these midseason trends can shape second-half strategy.
Want deals on what you love?
Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.
Meet Val