ValyouNewsExploreMeet Val
Sports

Orioles Keep Pete Alonso Off the Trade Block Amid Offseason Overhaul

Essentially Sports · November 5, 2026

Key takeaways

A Disappointing 2026 Forces Change

The Orioles were supposed to be building toward another deep playoff run. Instead, they stumbled to a 79-82 finish, landed fourth in a loaded AL East, and watched October happen without them. That's a tough pill for a team that made the postseason in both 2023 and 2024 with a young, talented core. New GM Jared Banner is now tasked with figuring out what went wrong — and fixing it fast.

Everyone's Available... Except Pete Alonso

According to MLB Network's Matt Vasgersian, Baltimore is reportedly willing to listen on trading almost anyone on the roster as it retools for 2027. But there's one clear exception: Pete Alonso isn't going anywhere. After signing a five-year, $155 million deal, Alonso delivered exactly what Baltimore paid for in his first season with the club — 43 home runs, 113 RBIs, and an .885 OPS, leading the entire American League in both homers and RBIs. He also played in all but one game, giving the lineup rare durability at a premium power position.

Why Alonso Stays Put

It's not complicated. Alonso just turned in one of the best offensive seasons in baseball, and replacing that kind of production isn't realistic in-house right now. Trading him would mean asking an unproven hitter to fill a 113-RBI void while the team is also trying to patch holes elsewhere. Yes, he'll turn 32 before the 2027 season, and the back half of that contract carries some risk. But for a team that just missed the playoffs and needs stability more than ever, Alonso represents a known quantity in a lineup that otherwise has question marks.

The Real Problem: Pitching

If Alonso isn't the issue, what is? Look no further than the rotation. Baltimore's starters posted a 4.24 ERA, good for just 17th in MLB — not nearly good enough for a team with postseason aspirations. Brandon Young was a genuine bright spot, throwing 156.2 innings with a 3.56 ERA, but the Orioles got shaky, inconsistent results from their veteran starters behind him. That's the real target for Banner and Mike Elias this offseason: upgrading the rotation and shoring up outfield depth, likely by moving other pieces to bring in arms.

What This Means Going Forward

This is a telling move from a front office that's clearly trying to be strategic rather than reactive. Instead of blowing up the whole roster after a disappointing year, Baltimore is protecting its best asset and targeting the specific weaknesses that actually cost them games. Expect a busy winter of outfield and rotation shopping, with Alonso's name staying firmly off the table no matter who comes calling.

Why it matters

For Orioles fans, this signals that the front office sees Alonso as a franchise cornerstone, not a trade chip, even amid a broader roster shake-up. It also clarifies where Baltimore's real needs lie heading into a pivotal offseason: starting pitching and outfield depth.

#MLB#Baltimore Orioles#Pete Alonso#MLB Trade Rumors#AL East

Source: Essentially Sports

Want deals on what you love?

Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.

Meet Val