Tarik Skubal Sweepstakes: Why Mets, Blue Jays Could Finally Beat the Dodgers
Fansided · November 19, 2026
Key takeaways
- Buster Olney reports the Skubal bidding war is expected to come down to the Mets and Blue Jays.
- Both franchises have failed to beat the Dodgers for stars like Tucker, Yamamoto, and Ohtani in recent years.
- Disappointing 2025 seasons give both teams extra motivation and financial urgency to close this deal.
The Report That Has Fans Cautiously Optimistic
ESPN's Buster Olney dropped a tweet that sent Mets and Blue Jays fans into a familiar spiral: insiders expect the Tarik Skubal bidding war to come down to New York and Toronto. Sounds great, right? Except fans of both franchises have heard this song before — and it usually ends with a star player in Dodger blue.
Last offseason's Kyle Tucker chase is the cautionary tale everyone's pointing to. The Blue Jays reportedly offered a 10-year deal. The Mets kept dangling absurd AAVs on shorter terms. And Tucker still didn't pick either of them. Before that, Yoshinobu Yamamoto and even Trevor Bauer used Mets interest purely as negotiating leverage before landing in Los Angeles. Shohei Ohtani ran a similar play using the Blue Jays. The pattern is real, and it's earned, which is exactly why skepticism is the default reaction this time around.
Why This Chase Might Actually Be Different
Here's the case for optimism: both the Mets and Blue Jays are coming off genuinely disappointing seasons. Both started the year with legitimate World Series expectations and finished with losing records and no playoff baseball. That kind of disappointment tends to create urgency — and urgency tends to loosen front offices' wallets and raise their willingness to go all-in on a true difference-maker.
Skubal isn't just another name on the market. He's arguably the best pitcher available, a legitimate ace who could instantly transform a rotation and signal to a fanbase that the front office is serious about contending again. For organizations stinging from underachievement, landing a player like that isn't just a baseball move — it's a statement.
What Makes Skubal's Market Different From Tucker's
Tucker was an elite bat, but star pitching carries a different kind of market gravity. Fewer teams can credibly offer a true ace the kind of long-term security and role clarity that Skubal will want, and both the Mets and Blue Jays have the financial might to make eye-popping offers without blinking. The Dodgers, despite their track record of winning these races, also have a crowded, expensive rotation picture already — meaning their motivation and roster fit may not align as cleanly as it did for previous targets.
None of this guarantees anything. The Dodgers have made a habit of closing these deals, and ruling them out would be premature. But between the motivation, the money, and the slightly different market dynamics of a pitcher versus a position player, there's a real argument that this time, the ending changes.
Why it matters
If either the Mets or Blue Jays land Skubal, it reshapes the entire AL/NL playoff picture and ends a frustrating streak of losing star free agents to the Dodgers. For fans, it's a referendum on whether big-market spending actually translates into landing the guy.
Want deals on what you love?
Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.
Meet Val