Tarik Skubal Sweepstakes: Padres Jump Dodgers, Mets Stay in Pole Position
Essentially Sports · November 11, 2026
Key takeaways
- Jon Heyman reports the Padres have passed the Dodgers for the No. 2 spot in Tarik Skubal's free agency race, with the Mets still No. 1.
- The Dodgers' hesitation stems from Andrew Friedman's preference for shorter deals, Skubal's elbow surgery, and an already massive luxury tax bill.
- San Diego has strong motivation to land Skubal since their rotation is thin behind Randy Vásquez heading into 2027.
The Market Just Flipped on Tarik Skubal
If you had the Dodgers penciled in as Tarik Skubal's next team, grab an eraser. According to insider Jon Heyman, the San Diego Padres have leapfrogged the Dodgers into the No. 2 spot in the Skubal sweepstakes — with the Mets still sitting comfortably at No. 1.
That's a real shake-up. The Dodgers were long considered the Mets' biggest threat for the two-time AL Cy Young winner. Now they're watching from the outside looking in.
Why the Dodgers Are Pumping the Brakes
This isn't about doubting Skubal's talent — he posted a 2.72 ERA and 0.96 WHIP over 26 starts in 2026, numbers that could land him a deal bigger than Yoshinobu Yamamoto's record $325 million contract. The hesitation comes down to two things: philosophy and health.
President of baseball ops Andrew Friedman has shown a clear preference for shorter, higher-AAV deals — see Kyle Tucker's four-year, $240 million contract. An eight-to-ten-year commitment to a pitcher turning 30 on November 20 just doesn't fit that mold.
Then there's the medical file. Skubal had surgery to remove loose bodies/fragments from his left elbow, missing roughly five and a half weeks and finishing 2026 with only 158.2 innings, down from 195.1 the year before. Add in an already massive Dodgers payroll — around $430 million against the luxury tax, with an estimated $180 million tax bill — and it's easy to see why LA is cooling off.
Why San Diego Is All In
Where the Dodgers see risk, the Padres see necessity. San Diego won 91 games and made the NLDS in 2026, but their rotation cupboard is bare heading into next season. Right-hander Randy Vásquez is the only returning pitcher with more than six starts last year, and both Casey Mize and Robbie Ray look like long shots to return.
For a team that just proved it can win now, landing a true ace like Skubal could be the difference between a playoff appearance and a deep run. San Diego has the motivation — the question is whether they have the wallet to actually close the deal.
Where the Mets Stand
Through all this movement, one thing hasn't changed: the Mets remain the favorites. New York has the payroll flexibility and has been aggressively positioning itself as the top suitor since the offseason began. Unless something dramatic happens, Queens looks like the most likely landing spot.
What Happens Next
Skubal's camp is holding most of the cards here. With the Mets steady at the top and the Padres now surging past a reluctant Dodgers squad, this is shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable free-agent chases of the offseason. Buckle up — the next few weeks could get loud.
Why it matters
A Cy Young-caliber ace changing the free agent board this late shakes up every contender's offseason plans. Whoever lands Skubal instantly becomes a World Series threat, so this decision will ripple through the entire National League.
Want deals on what you love?
Val finds local offers matched to your interests — free to start.
Meet Val